| Platinum | Yours Conveniently |
| Gold | Metropolis Mercantile + Café |
| Gold | This Little Café TLC |
| Silver | Chatime |
| Bronze | Goblets and Goblins |
| Top Pick | Brew It |
| Top Pick | Cardinal Press Espresso Bar |
| Top Pick | Mercato On Main |
| Top Pick | My Indie Coffee |
| Top Pick | The Lazy Daisy Cafe |